Milk Pail fresh market Pick Up Service

We are still open at our main store during these unfamiliar times, but we wanted to offer another option for shopping.  Want the amazing taste of fresh locally grown produce and your favorite farm stand items ready to go for pick up?  Here's your option... shop online at Milk Pail fresh market and we will pack up your items and have them ready for pick up at our store located at 1346 Montauk Hwy, Water Mill, NY.


How does this work?

Choose the items you would like.  Add them to your cart and check out.  We will receive your order and email you when it’s ready to be picked up!  It’s as easy as that.  Just make sure to include an email address so that we can let you know when the order is ready.


Please keep in mind in these unfamiliar times our items are subject to change.  Our in house made items are readily available, but those items we bring in tend to change.  If need be we may have to substitute an item.  We will do our best to keep the website up to date with all the extra items.  If we don’t have something today, check again in a few days.

Leaves us any special instructions when checking out. 
Orders placed need to be picked up the same day.  O
rders placed after 4pm can be picked up the next day. Thank you!!!


Halsey Family
Over 350 years of farming.
Family Farm
Share our family favorites.
Donut Peaches
Sweet & Juicy
Juicy Apples
Over 30 varieties including ones you've never seen before!
Farm Fresh
Harvested Fresh!

Milk Pail fresh market

Celebrating over 50 years of farm fresh apples, peaches, blueberries, pears, and pumpkins.  Enjoy our products made fresh with our produce.  Homemade goodies just like Grandma used to make.

Instagram feed

Left Continue shopping
Your Order

You have no items in your cart